PGR vs ALL: Fair Value Comparison

Progressive Corp vs. The Allstate Corporation · Property & Casualty Insurance

PGR's model fair value sits 15.7% below its current price; ALL's model fair value sits 47.5% above its current price. Of the two, ALL trades further below its model estimate. Model estimates under stated assumptions. Data as of 2026-10-22.

PGRALL
Price$229.60$259.09
Model fair value (multi-method blend)$193.57$382.03
Model fair value differential-15.7%+47.5%
Methods with a model value above price5 of 103 of 12
Fundamental strengthA-A-
Next earnings report—2026-11-04

Differential = model fair value versus the current price; positive means the price sits below the model estimate.

More comparisons

CB vs PGR · PGR vs TRV · PGR vs WRB · CB vs ALL · TRV vs ALL · ALL vs WRB · All Property & Casualty Insurance stocks · Compare any two stocks