AIG vs ACGL: Fair Value Comparison

American International Group Inc vs. Arch Capital Group Ltd. · Diversified Insurance

AIG's model fair value sits 8.0% above its current price; ACGL's model fair value sits 28.1% above its current price. Of the two, ACGL trades further below its model estimate. Model estimates under stated assumptions. Data as of 2026-10-22.

AIGACGL
Price$82.91$103.38
Model fair value (multi-method blend)$89.55$132.44
Model fair value differential+8.0%+28.1%
Methods with a model value above price4 of 113 of 10
Fundamental strengthB-B+
Next earnings report2026-11-032026-10-27

Differential = model fair value versus the current price; positive means the price sits below the model estimate.

More comparisons

BRK-B vs AIG · AIG vs HIG · BRK-B vs ACGL · HIG vs ACGL · All Diversified Insurance stocks · Compare any two stocks